The first motion application is the gateway to the NCLT scheme process. It is not a mere formality; it is the stage at which the Tribunal satisfies itself that the scheme is fit for consideration by the affected classes. A defective first motion application delays the process, invites objections, and may result in the rejection of the application at the threshold.
The Statutory Basis and the Documents
Section 230(1) permits the company or any creditor or member to apply to the Tribunal for an order convening a meeting of creditors or members. The application must be accompanied by the scheme, the board resolution approving the scheme, the latest audited financial statements, and the valuation report, where applicable.
The Companies (Compromises, Arrangements and Amalgamations) Rules, 2016 prescribe the form and contents of the application. The application must disclose the particulars of the company, the scheme, the classes of members and creditors affected, and the proposed date, time, and venue of the meetings. The application must also disclose any pending proceedings, any regulatory approvals required, and any objections received.
The Directions Sought
The first motion order is not a sanction of the scheme. It is a procedural order that sets the machinery of the scheme in motion. The order typically directs the company to convene meetings of the classes of members and creditors, appoints a chairperson for each meeting, prescribes the notice period, the quorum, and the voting method, and directs the company to serve notice on the statutory authorities.
The order may dispense with the meetings of a class where the requisite consent has been obtained. The dispensation is not automatic; the Tribunal must be satisfied that the consent is genuine, that it represents the requisite value, and that the dispensation is in the interest of the class.
The Objections at the First Motion Stage
The first motion stage is not the stage for a merits review of the scheme. The Tribunal's jurisdiction is limited to determining whether the scheme should be placed before the affected classes. However, the Tribunal may reject the application if the scheme is not authorised by the memorandum or articles, if the application is not accompanied by the required documents, or if the scheme is ex facie unlawful.
The NCLAT has held that the first motion stage is not the appropriate stage for a detailed examination of the commercial merits of the scheme. The objections on merits are to be raised at the second motion stage, after the meetings have been held and the chairperson's reports have been filed.
A first motion application that is complete, candid, and procedurally compliant is the foundation of a scheme that can withstand scrutiny at the second motion stage.
Call to Action
Anuj Desai & Associates advises companies on the drafting and filing of first motion applications—from the compilation of documents and the valuation report to the proposed directions and the response to objections. If you are initiating an NCLT scheme, we can help you build a first motion record that accelerates the process.
📧 office@anujdesaiassociates.com
📞 9619456656
🌐 https://anujdesaiassociates.com
🔗 linkedin.com/in/ca-anuj-desai-122547230
Article 73